The home you'd buy
The rent you'd pay
The assumptions
Defaults are the worked example below, so the first numbers you see are already checked.
The verdict
After 10 years, in net worth
—
—
Where the money goes (buying, 10 years)
Unrecoverable costs are the money owning burns that renting never pays — interest, tax, upkeep, insurance, fees, CMHC and selling costs. The principal you repay is not burned: it becomes your equity.
Year by year
| Year | Home value | Mortgage left | Buy net worth | Rent net worth | Buying ahead by |
|---|
How the math works (2026 Canadian rules)
- Ontario land transfer tax: 0.5% on the first $55,000, 1% to $250,000, 1.5% to $400,000, 2% to $2,000,000, 2.5% above that. On a $650,000 home that is $275 + $1,950 + $2,250 + $5,000 = $9,475. First-time buyers of a principal residence get up to $4,000 back. Toronto adds its own municipal land transfer tax on top — this page counts the provincial tax only.
- CMHC insurance: mandatory when the down payment is under 20%. Premium is a percentage of the mortgage, added to the loan: 4.00% with 5–9.99% down, 3.10% with 10–14.99%, 2.80% with 15–19.99%; a 30-year amortization adds 0.20 points. On a $600,000 home with 5% down the premium is $22,800 on a $570,000 mortgage — $592,800 borrowed. Ontario also charges 8% PST on the premium at closing (not counted here — add it to your closing costs if it applies).
- Minimum down payment: 5% on the first $500,000, 10% on the portion from $500,000 to $1,500,000, 20% at $1,500,000 and over (insured mortgages are capped at $1.5M). The page warns you if your down payment is below the federal minimum.
- The mortgage: Canadian mortgages compound semi-annually, so the monthly rate is (1 + rate ÷ 2)1/6 − 1, not rate ÷ 12. The payment is fixed for the whole horizon in this model — in reality the rate changes at every renewal, usually every 5 years.
- The fair comparison: both paths start with the same cash and spend the same each month. The buyer puts the down payment + closing costs into the home; the renter invests that same cash. Every month, whoever's housing costs less invests the difference — the renter's portfolio grows by the gap between owning and renting, and shrinks if rent ever costs more than owning. Net worth buying = home value − 5% selling costs − mortgage left. Net worth renting = the portfolio. The break-even year is the first year buying is at least level.
- What the model assumes: home value grows steadily at your rate; rent rises steadily at yours; investments return steadily at yours; property tax and upkeep are a fixed share of a growing home value; condo fees are held flat (flattering to buying); tenant insurance is $30/month; the home is a principal residence, so its gain is tax-free and the investment return entered is already after fees and tax. Real years vary wildly — the point is the sensitivity, not the forecast. Change the appreciation to 0% and watch the answer flip.
- What this leaves out: Toronto's municipal land transfer tax, the 8% Ontario PST on the CMHC premium, moving costs, the value of your time spent on upkeep, rent control rules beyond the guideline, the Smith Manoeuvre, and — the biggest one — the fact that a home is also where you live: stability, control over the space, and not being renovicted are worth real money that no spreadsheet prices.
Worked example (the defaults): a $650,000 home, 20% down ($130,000), 4.29% over 25 years, rent $2,400/month for a similar home, 10-year horizon. Land transfer tax $9,475 + $2,500 other closing + $130,000 down = $141,975 cash up front. No CMHC at 20% down, so the mortgage is $520,000 and the payment is $2,817.67/month (semi-annual compounding). All-in owning costs $3,917.67 in month 1 against $2,430 renting — the renter invests the $1,487.67 difference every month. After 10 years the home is worth $873,545.65, the mortgage left is $374,495.85, so buying net worth is $873,545.65 × 0.95 − $374,495.85 = $455,372.51; the renter's portfolio is $442,724.92. Buying comes out ahead by $12,647.59, and first pulls ahead in year 9. Interest over the 10 years: $192,616.25.
Worked example 2 — the small-down-payment case: a $600,000 home, 5% down ($30,000 — below the $35,000 federal minimum for a $600,000 home, so treat this as illustrative), first-time buyer, rent $2,200/month. Land transfer tax $8,475 − $4,000 first-time refund = $4,475; cash up front $36,975. CMHC premium 4.00% × $570,000 = $22,800, so the mortgage is $592,800 and the payment is $3,212.14/month. After 10 years buying net worth is $339,106.49 against the renter's $353,535.90 — renting wins by $14,429.41, and buying never pulls ahead inside the 10 years. The CMHC premium and the thin equity are doing the damage.
The 5% rule: a quick check before you run the numbers — if a year of rent costs less than about 5% of the price of a similar home, renting and investing the difference often comes out ahead; if it costs more, buying often does. The defaults here: $2,400 × 12 = $28,800 a year, which is 4.4% of $650,000 — under 5%, and buying still wins by year 9 because the home appreciates 3% a year. The rule is a starting point, not a verdict.
Rates verified November 18, 2026: CMHC premium tiers 4.00% / 3.10% / 2.80% (plus 0.20 points for 30-year amortization) and the minimum-down-payment tiers, checked against CMHC's published schedule and multiple 2026 Canadian guides; Ontario land transfer tax brackets checked against the province's schedule and cross-checked against the Maple Key Mortgage calculator's verified $9,475 figure on a $650,000 home; Ontario's 2027 rent-increase guideline of 1.9% and the Bank of Canada's July 2026 average 3-to-5-year fixed rates (4.08% uninsured, 3.99% insured) noted from published sources. A planning estimate, not financial advice: get a real mortgage quote and a realtor's read on the home before you decide.